The Best of Ithaca NY

Introduction

Ithaca, New York, is a small city with an outsized reputation for natural beauty, academic excellence, and vibrant local culture. From renowned restaurants and top-ranked schools to scenic neighborhoods and tourist attractions, Ithaca offers a well-rounded experience for residents and visitors alike. The following guide highlights 10 of the best restaurants in Ithaca, seamlessly weaving in information on the city’s best schools, desirable neighborhoods, and fun tourist destinations to help you plan your visit or relocation.

Moosewood Restaurant

Moosewood Restaurant is arguably Ithaca’s most famous dining destination, known worldwide for its pioneering vegetarian cuisine and bestselling cookbooks. Located in the historic Dewitt Mall in Downtown Ithaca, Moosewood emphasizes fresh, seasonal, and locally sourced ingredients. Its globally inspired menu, with hearty soups, innovative salads, and creative entrées, makes it a must-visit for both vegetarians and omnivores.

The restaurant sits near the Ithaca Commons, a pedestrian-friendly hub lined with boutiques, cafés, and entertainment venues. This central area is one of the city’s most desirable places to spend time and is closely linked to some of Ithaca’s best neighborhoods, including Fall Creek and Northside. Families drawn to this part of town also benefit from access to well-regarded Ithaca City School District elementary schools.

Coltivare

Coltivare is a farm-to-table restaurant that showcases the agricultural richness of the Finger Lakes region. Operated in partnership with Tompkins Cortland Community College’s culinary program, Coltivare offers a refined yet approachable menu featuring house-made pastas, farm-fresh vegetables, and locally raised meats. Its sleek, modern interior and open kitchen make it ideal for a special night out in Downtown Ithaca.

Because of its connection to local education, Coltivare underscores Ithaca’s broader commitment to learning and sustainability. Nearby, you will find easy access to several top schools and a short drive to Cornell University and Ithaca College, both of which anchor the city’s reputation as a premier academic center. Visitors can dine here before heading to cultural attractions on the hilltop campuses, including museums, galleries, and performance spaces.

Mahogany Grill

Mahogany Grill, situated at the edge of the Ithaca Commons, offers classic American fare with a sophisticated twist. Known for its steaks, seafood, and extensive wine list, it delivers a warm, upscale atmosphere that appeals to both locals and tourists. Its outdoor seating in warmer months provides a front-row seat to downtown activity, making it one of the best restaurants in Ithaca for people-watching.

The central location also makes Mahogany Grill a convenient starting point for exploring Ithaca’s fun tourist destinations, such as the State Theatre of Ithaca for live performances or nearby Six Mile Creek for hiking. Prospective residents drawn to the lively downtown environment often explore South Hill and East Hill neighborhoods, which offer a mix of student-friendly and family-oriented housing options.

Just a Taste

Just a Taste is a beloved tapas and wine bar tucked near the Commons. Its ever-changing menu of small plates encourages sharing and sampling, while the thoughtfully curated wine list highlights both Finger Lakes vintages and international selections. The intimate setting and attentive service make it a popular choice for date nights and gatherings with friends.

This restaurant is also a great stop before or after exploring Ithaca’s nightlife, with nearby bars, cafés, and live music venues. The area’s walkability, cultural events, and proximity to top schools, including highly regarded middle and high schools in the Ithaca City School District, make the surrounding neighborhoods especially attractive to young professionals and families.

Saigon Kitchen

Saigon Kitchen is widely considered one of the best Asian restaurants in Ithaca, specializing in authentic Vietnamese cuisine. Pho, bun bowls, fresh spring rolls, and flavorful curries are prepared with care, drawing both students and long-term residents. The restaurant’s stylish yet relaxed environment and consistently high-quality dishes have earned it a loyal following.

Located a short drive from the Cornell University campus and the lively Collegetown neighborhood, Saigon Kitchen is well-positioned for visitors exploring campus landmarks, such as the Cornell Botanic Gardens or the iconic clock tower. These areas are also near some of Ithaca’s most convenient neighborhoods for students, faculty, and staff, offering a blend of historic housing and modern apartments.

Kyushu Hibachi and Sushi

Kyushu Hibachi and Sushi brings Japanese flavors to Ithaca with an engaging hibachi experience and a full sushi bar. Diners can enjoy expertly prepared rolls, sashimi, and grilled entrées while watching chefs perform tableside. This interactive dining style makes Kyushu a popular choice for celebrations and group outings.

Its location near major roadways provides quick access to suburban neighborhoods such as Lansing and Northeast Ithaca, which are known for strong public schools, including highly rated elementary programs. Families often choose these neighborhoods for their balance of quiet residential streets, shopping centers, and easy access to both Cornell and downtown attractions.

Gola Osteria

Gola Osteria is a hidden gem for upscale Italian dining, nestled in the historic Quarry Arms building near East Hill. With house-made pastas, rich sauces, and an extensive wine list, Gola Osteria offers one of the most refined dining experiences in Ithaca. The cozy, brick-walled interior and attentive service make it ideal for special occasions.

This restaurant is conveniently situated between Cornell University and several desirable residential enclaves, including Belle Sherman and East Hill neighborhoods. These areas are prized for their tree-lined streets, walkability to campus, and access to some of Ithaca’s best elementary schools, making them top choices for academic professionals and families.

Mix Kitchen and Bar

Mix Kitchen and Bar lives up to its name by blending global flavors into inventive small plates and shared dishes. From creative tacos to Asian-inspired specialties, the eclectic menu invites diners to explore a range of tastes in a stylish, contemporary space. Its brunch offerings are especially popular, attracting weekend crowds from across the city.

Located near South Hill, Mix is close to Ithaca College and a short drive from notable attractions such as Buttermilk Falls State Park. This area appeals to those seeking convenient access to both natural beauty and urban amenities, and the surrounding neighborhoods offer a mix of student housing and more established family homes.

Maxies Supper Club and Oyster Bar

Maxies Supper Club and Oyster Bar brings a New Orleans–inspired flair to Ithaca’s dining scene. Known for its fresh oysters, po’boys, and Southern comfort food, Maxies pairs bold flavors with a lively atmosphere. Seasonal outdoor seating and frequent live music contribute to its reputation as one of the city’s most enjoyable places to eat and relax.

Situated not far from the Cascadilla Creek gorge and the artsy Fall Creek neighborhood, Maxies provides easy access to scenic walking routes and family-friendly parks. Fall Creek itself is often highlighted as one of Ithaca’s best neighborhoods, with a strong sense of community, local cafés, and proximity to well-regarded elementary schools.

Ithaca Beer Co

Ithaca Beer Co is more than a brewery; it is a full-service restaurant and a quintessential Finger Lakes experience. The expansive taproom and farm-like outdoor space feature a menu built around wood-fired pizzas, hearty pub fare, and seasonal specials, all designed to pair with the brewery’s renowned craft beers. Visitors can tour the brewery, relax on the lawn, and enjoy panoramic views of the surrounding countryside.

Located a short drive from downtown, Ithaca Beer Co is conveniently positioned en route to popular natural attractions like Buttermilk Falls State Park and Robert H. Treman State Park, both of which are among the top tourist destinations in the region. Many people who fall in love with these landscapes choose to settle in nearby neighborhoods on South Hill or in the surrounding townships, attracted by a blend of rural charm, good schools, and easy access to the city’s vibrant restaurant scene.

• Best Restaurants in Ithaca NY